Afghanistan: Taliban ‘cooperating’ with UK forces and not behaving in ‘medieval way’, says chief of defence staff
“We are cooperating with the Taliban on the ground and that seems to be a very straightforward relationship,” General Sir Nick Carter tells Sky News.
News reporter @samuelosborne93
Wednesday 18 August 2021 10:41, UKThe Taliban is “cooperating” with British forces as they work to evacuate people from Afghanistan and is not behaving in a “medieval way”, the chief of the UK defence staff has said.
General Sir Nick Carter told Sky News: “We are cooperating with the Taliban on the ground and that seems to be a very straightforward relationship.
“They are keeping the streets of Kabul very safe and indeed very calm. They are helping us at the airport.”
He said the militants are “keeping the streets calm, they are avoiding public disorder” – and added: “What we’re not getting are reports of them behaving in a medieval way like you might have seen in the past.”
Sir Nick suggested the Islamist movement, which has taken power in Afghanistan, could be more moderate than when it was last in control in the 1990s.
He said he does not think the Taliban “want to become international pariahs again”, adding: “I do think that they have changed.”
However, the shadow foreign secretary Lisa Nandy disagreed with Sir Nick’s comments, saying the UK is “dealing with a very oppressive regime”.
“I think that’s a very difficult and unpalatable message to the very many Afghans, including women and girls, who are not just suffering at the moment but are also very, very fearful about the future,” she told Sky News.
“I spoke to a friend from Afghanistan last week who told me the Taliban were going door-to-door, they were arresting people, they were threatening people who’d worked with British troops or women who’d worked in high profile jobs.
“I think we ought to be talking to the Taliban, that’s absolutely right. But we ought to be talking to the Taliban about getting guarantees around human rights and the future for women and girls.”
She added: “I think it’s very difficult to judge people by their words when their actions are so at odds with the reality. I think we’re dealing with a very oppressive regime and I think we need to be clear-eyed about that.”
WHY DO PEOPLE FEAR THE TALIBAN?
The Taliban was condemned internationally for enforcing a strict and extreme version of Sharia law during its rule from 1996 to 2001, which included administering punishments such as public stonings, whippings and hangings.
The militant group also banned music and musical instruments, with the exception of the daf – a type of frame drum – and cut off the hands of thieves and stoned adulterers.
Along with their allies, they committed massacres against Afghan civilians, denied UN food supplies to 160,000 starving people, and conducted a policy of scorched earth – burning vast areas of fertile land and destroying tens of thousands of homes.
Under the Taliban’s ruling, activities and media including paintings, photography and movies that depicted people or other living things were banned.
Many Afghans fear the Taliban will reimpose this harsh interpretation of Islamic law – leading to thousands of people trying to flee the country.
It comes as Boris Johnson told MPs that events in Afghanistan “unfolded” faster “than even the Taliban predicted”, but he said the government had not been caught “unawares”.
MPs have been recalled from their summer holidays for an emergency sitting in Parliament on Wednesday to take part in a five-hour debate on the situation in Afghanistan.On Tuesday night, the prime minister announced a new settlement scheme will allow up to 20,000 vulnerable Afghan refugees to come to the UK over the coming years.
The Taliban has claimed it is not seeking revenge after regaining control of the country after being ousted two decades ago.
Speaking from the Afghan presidential palace on Tuesday, Zabihullah Mujahid referred to Afghanistan as the “Islamic Emirate” and said the group is committed to the rights of women within the framework of Sharia, or Islamic law.
Meanwhile, Taliban spokesman Suhail Shaheen told Sky News that “thousands” of schools continue to operate following the Taliban takeover and claimed women will have the right to work and be educated up to university level.